Corporate, Commercial Law and Dispute Resolution · Contracts, Commercial Law and Transactions
Tax notice-decision appeal allows a taxpayer to challenge additional liabilities, penalties or other conclusions issued by the tax authority when the taxpayer disputes the factual basis, calculation or legality of the decision. The available strategy may use administrative review, court proceedings or both in the sequence permitted by Ukrainian procedure.
Successful appeal depends on the evidence underlying the notice-decision, the procedural history of the audit and a clear explanation of where the tax authority's position conflicts with the documents or applicable rules.
Administrative Appeal
Administrative review is used when the taxpayer disagrees with the assessed liability or considers that the tax authority exceeded its powers or applied the law incorrectly. The complaint is filed with the competent higher tax authority under the applicable procedure.
This route can resolve the dispute without immediate court costs and may also clarify the authority's arguments before litigation becomes necessary.
Court Appeal
If administrative review does not produce an acceptable result, the taxpayer may challenge the tax notice-decision in court. A 1,095-day period is stated for judicial appeal, while the tax authority must substantiate the legality of its decision in the proceedings.
Evidence and Legal Position
Review should cover incoming and outgoing correspondence, audit materials, accounting and contractual documents, calculations and the reasoning stated in the notice-decision. Contradictions between the evidence and the tax authority's conclusions should be identified before the complaint or claim is filed.
Appeal Work
development of the legal position;
analysis of the documents that led to the notice-decision;
preparation of an administrative complaint;
representation during pre-trial tax review;
analysis of relevant court practice where required;
preparation of the statement of claim for court proceedings;
representation through the judicial stages of the dispute.
Recommended Sequence
Work normally starts with document review and assessment of the facts, followed by preparation of the required complaint, explanations or procedural documents. Meetings and negotiations with the tax authority may be used where they can clarify or resolve the dispute.
Documents Used to Challenge the Assessment
Source material places document comparison at the centre of the appeal. Audit materials, tax calculations, declarations, primary accounting documents, contracts and correspondence should be compared with the reasoning in the notice-decision so that each disputed conclusion is answered with a factual and legal counter-position. Missing deadlines or an incomplete evidence package can weaken an otherwise valid objection.
Tax notice-decision defence strategy should preserve deadlines and build one consistent evidence-based position for both administrative and judicial review. A structured appeal can reduce unnecessary litigation costs and improve the prospects of cancelling or reducing an unsupported tax assessment.
Why is it better with us?
The principal activities of the UBC group of companies are consulting, financial and investment services, search and selection of investors for business and attraction of loans, purchase and sale of established businesses in Ukraine, Europe and other countries, IT services, and development of commercial real estate in Ukraine and abroad. For the development of your business: registration of enterprises in Ukraine, ready-made companies in the EU, registration of companies in England and other countries, corporate law, offshore jurisdictions and offshore companies, business consulting, audit, certification, registration of LLCs, registration of financial companies, asset management companies, mutual investment funds, registration of joint-stock companies, issue of securities and bonds, and support for foreign investment.
The continuously expanding range of regional and foreign partners directly helps resolve our clients’ issues when conducting business both in Ukraine and abroad.
We are always focused on the result you need and will do everything to achieve it within the required timeframe, taking your wishes and requirements into detailed account! Why is it better to start business in Ukraine with UBC? The answer is simple - we have much more practical experience, resources and opportunities.
Price: Appealing a Tax Notice-Decision in Ukraine