Corporate, Commercial Law and Dispute Resolution · Corporate Law
General meeting resolution challenge is available where a corporate decision breaches applicable rules, constitutional documents or the rights of a shareholder or company participant. Strong evidence on notice, voting, quorum and the effect of the resolution is central to deciding whether a challenge is commercially justified.
General meetings of company participants and shareholders adopt decisions that shape corporate governance and major business actions. Resolution may be challenged where the meeting procedure, voting process or participant rights were materially affected.
Breach of the Meeting Convocation Procedure
Before a meeting is held, all participants or shareholders must be notified properly and in due time of the date, time, place and agenda.
Common violations include:
failure to notify individual participants;
failure to comply with notification deadlines;
a discrepancy between the actual agenda and the agenda stated in the notice;
use of an improper form of notice.
Such violations may indicate that participants were deprived of the opportunity to exercise their right to participate in the meeting.
Lack of Quorum
Quorum means the minimum number of votes or participants required for resolutions to be adopted. If the participants present at the meeting do not constitute the required quorum, the resolutions may be declared invalid.
Breach of the Decision-Making Procedure
In practice, resolutions may sometimes be adopted without discussion, in breach of voting procedures, without recording the actual voting results or without the participation of certain members.
Examples include:
falsification of voting results;
voting without registration of those present;
refusing participants an opportunity to state their position.
Unlawful Content of the Resolution
A resolution may conflict with:
the applicable legislation of Ukraine;
the company's charter;
the rights and legitimate interests of individual participants.
Examples include resolutions to dispose of assets without complying with statutory requirements or resolutions that restrict the rights of minority shareholders.
Defects in the Form or Content of the Minutes
The meeting minutes are the official record of the resolutions adopted. If they contain procedural defects, such as missing signatures, unconfirmed amendments or discrepancies between what actually occurred at the meeting and the text of the minutes, this may provide grounds for a challenge.
Falsification of Documents
Any document forgery, including forged signatures, alteration of the minutes after signature or similar conduct, is a serious ground for seeking invalidation of the resolutions.
How Is a Resolution Challenged?
Preparing the Evidence
Documents and evidence supporting the alleged violations should be collected, including notices, correspondence, audio and video recordings, expert opinions and other materials.
Filing a Claim with the Court
The claim is filed with the commercial court at the location of the legal entity.
Proving the Violations in Court
The court examines the circumstances of the case, including compliance with the procedures for convening the meeting, voting and adopting resolutions.
Time Limit for Challenging a Resolution
The general limitation period for challenging general meeting resolutions is three years from the date on which the participant became aware, or should have become aware, of the infringement of their rights.
Delay is nevertheless undesirable because evidence is easier to secure and rights are generally easier to protect when action is taken promptly.
Challenging general meeting resolutions is an instrument for protecting the corporate rights of business participants. A successful claim requires proper preparation and a well-supported evidentiary record.
Resolution challenge strategy should distinguish a material infringement from a technical defect that does not affect corporate rights. Focused evidence and a clear commercial objective reduce unnecessary litigation and improve the chances of obtaining a useful result.
Why is it better with us?
The principal activities of the UBC group of companies are consulting, financial and investment services, search and selection of investors for business and attraction of loans, purchase and sale of established businesses in Ukraine, Europe and other countries, IT services, and development of commercial real estate in Ukraine and abroad. For the development of your business: registration of enterprises in Ukraine, ready-made companies in the EU, registration of companies in England and other countries, corporate law, offshore jurisdictions and offshore companies, business consulting, audit, certification, registration of LLCs, registration of financial companies, asset management companies, mutual investment funds, registration of joint-stock companies, issue of securities and bonds, and support for foreign investment.
The continuously expanding range of regional and foreign partners directly helps resolve our clients’ issues when conducting business both in Ukraine and abroad.
We are always focused on the result you need and will do everything to achieve it within the required timeframe, taking your wishes and requirements into detailed account! Why is it better to start business in Ukraine with UBC? The answer is simple - we have much more practical experience, resources and opportunities.
Price: Challenging a General Meeting Resolution in Ukraine